Editorial policy

How this site is written and reviewed

What the labels on each page mean, and what has not been checked.

Publication and clinical review

These are separate states. A page can be published while it has not been clinically reviewed, and the label on the page says so. Publication means the page has been edited and its sources recorded. Clinical review means a qualified practitioner has checked it.

Review status

Clinically reviewed appears only when a named reviewer, a date, the scope of the review and a fingerprint of the reviewed content are all recorded, and the current content still matches that fingerprint. If the page is edited afterwards, the review lapses and the page says that it is out of date.

Clinical review in progress means the page has been sent for review.

Not clinically reviewed means no review currently applies to the page.

AI editorial review identifies an educational page assessed by Codex against its cited sources. It includes a preliminary evidence and safety assessment, not examination of a patient or approval by a qualified clinician. Human clinical review remains pending and is stated on the page.

A review covers the scope recorded with it. A page may be reviewed for safety but not for classical citation, or the reverse.

Evidence

Statements about modern research are labelled and appraised. Each page records how much of its sources were read and what assessment was performed. Where a page has not been appraised, it says so. Counts of published studies describe how much has been written, not what it shows.

Sources

Each page lists its sources with a retrieval date. Traditional explanations are presented as traditional explanations, not as established clinical fact. Where sources are recorded as provisional, the page says so and the claims rest on a single secondary reference.

Our research approach

Articles are researched and written from independent sources: pharmacopoeias and official standards for identity, processing and quality; professional materia medica for traditional actions and combinations; and clinical or regulatory sources for safety and modern evidence. Each article records what was actually consulted and how deeply it was read. A source cited indirectly is identified as indirect.

Pages derived from older drafts are treated as unverified candidates until they are independently reconstructed. Draft pages may still be awaiting research, and their provisional-source and review labels remain visible until that work is complete.

Images

Images accompany articles to help explain medicinal materials and related topics. Captions identify the subject and preparation where relevant.